| I'm a fan of this method of conversion. I have had a lot of time to think about it since my first conversion project last year. That alternator has been up on my tower, producing power, for exactly 6 months, as of this writing. I am still grateful to the late Zubbly, who inspired that project.
But now that it's been running, of course it isn't perfect. The system suffers from 2 problems, as I see it:
1 The motor is so large, it is offset from the tower axis too much, and
2 The winding resistance is too high, making speed/power matching difficult.
Here's the candidate replacement:




The laminations of the rotor are 4.38" in diameter, and 2.88" long. There is enough room for 12 rows of 3/4" magents, or 8 rows of 1" magnets. I may stick with round magnets, and machine an aluminum cage. If anyone can provide some reports of this rotor construction working for a long time, hot and cold, please let me know. Despite what I've seen regarding construction, I have seen very little in follow-up on how it's holding up after a few winters. Gets below -40 here. On both thermometer scales.
Here's a surprise: when I look into the windings, I see only one layer in each slot. My previous belief was that the wire groups would "share" the slot, with a isolation card between them. Checking pictures of other motors and that is what I see. But not here. Does this indicate a different style of winding? I'm going to get out an old book I have on motor maintenance (Rosenberg's; highly recommended).
Since this is a 4-pole motor, and the winding resistance is virtually the same, I could build it just like the first one. This motor is at least 3 inches smaller in overall diameter than the big GE motor that's currently up on the tower. That would solve problem #1 above, but I'm greedy. :-)
Later I will be posting some analysis I've been doing with FEMM. Thanks to this fantastic tool, it looks like I can use the results to predict cut-in and performance.
I want to thank Peter for his recent detailed contribution about his latest conversion. I have learned a lot from that, too. (Peter, if you read this, can you shoot me an e-mail? I'd like to reverse-engineer your last conversion and there are a couple of very specific questions I'd like to ask. (Thanks). |
|
|
Total Views
|
|
143 Scoop users have viewed this posting.
|
|