Hi Tom,
Do you think the old story was from September 3, 2005, or March 9, 2005? Or does the apparent date in the URL have more to do with the date on which that member added it to the old hotlist? Hints that would help narrow down the search for the thread.
Before the board change-over last year (how time flies!) I put a lot of links in my hotlist into a separate set of favourites. They still work for me - but they wouldn't work for anyone else?