Yes, I am certain it will heat the room far better. Using convection only, the only air you can actually heat is what contacts the burner basically. That air transfers heat to other air, rises and lets cooler air hit the burner to be heated etc..
Now with say 50 little 2" aluminum spikes poking out the sides into the air, you see all the surface area you gain for the air to contact. The entire 2" will be hotter than the surrounding air, so it is all transfering heat. Add to that Aluminum will kinda SUCK the heat out of the steel, the steel transfers the heat better (sort of).
My thought on that is the fire is only going to raise the temp of the steel so high, once it gets to that max temp and is holding steady, any more heat generated will be rolling up the stack to the great outdoors. Cooling that steel as fast as posable means it can absorb more heat faster. Same as blowing a fan on it. I heat the room by convection only alot and it works fine, but when I really want the heat I turn on a fan and of course I get far more heat from the same fire. I don't change the fire, I just blow cold room air against the hot steel barrel to heat more air faster.
Also another things I think will work quite well with this new burner. I will be adding a fake linner (tank) in the top to force the fire more to the sides. I was watching in a peep hole (bung) in the barrel seveal times now and I see the flames rolling very nicly along the top of the barrel inside and flowing directly to the rear and up the stack, even with the damper closed. The top of my burner of course is far hotter than the sides are. On this new one I will be placing a tank inside hanging from the top about 2-3". What this "SHOULD" do is force the flames of the fire out around the bottom of the tank and to the side of the barrel, thus heateing the sides far more than now. It will still let the heat and flames reach the top also as they flow around the sides of the false tank and upwards.
I realy don't like it when the flames are shooting up the stack, one more thing I plan to try out is to block the front of the stack opening (coffee can use here) thus forcing any flames to sweep around to the rear of the stack opening.
In watching the wood burner alot recently, and after reading a post about an over ahead daft for the fire. I am thinking using 2 drafts will also improve the burner alot.
First you need some air to the coal under the fire so it can burn. But as we know from downdraft gasifiers and other stuff, the oxygen is burned up in the coals and produces heat that bakes out more gas from the wood. Now this extra gas is in an oxygen free inviroment and cannot burn, so up it goes out the stack. How much this happens in the wood burner depends o alot of things. How much draft to the coals, how much coals, etc.. But it is happening and that unburned gas is wasted feul that could be makng more heat! I have recently been burning my fires with the bung open on the wood burner. I built it so it was to the side about even with the top of the door.
Once I get a good fire going and lost of hot coals, I close the lower damper about 1/2-3/4 closed and open the 2" bung. The coals have air to burn but a slow draft on the bottom, so most the draft is from the 2" hole. This draft is above the wood and coals and is drawn to where ever it's needed basically. I have been seeing much more rolling gas ball flames inside the burner this way than before. The oxygen in the air entering through the higher 2" hole is getting to the gas and letting the gas burn up, I bealve much of that in the past was unburned due to lack of oxygen and simply went up the stack wasted and polutting. The air hitting the hot coals basically fanned the fire, coals burned hotter, oxygen depleated, gas unburned wnet up stack.
The problem I have with leaving the hole open is that it does let smoke into the house ocasionally of course if not a strong draft going and couple other minor things since it is high up on the barrel. So What I will be doing on this new burner is add a pipe to stop that, cap off the hole and run the pipe downward below the fire level outside the barrel, then the smoke can't flow out the upper hole since it would have to go downhill. Then I have the 3 dampers, one for the stack to outside, one for the bottom, one for the top. I should get a much better controlled burn.
I have some other things I plan to add to it after I get that much built.