I believe you misunderstand a dump load.
Your understanding of a dump load seems to involve stopping current from reaching the battery.
A dump load controller "Dumps" extra Battery power to a load.
Something that cuts off the extra power GOING TO the battery is OK with solar under certain conditions.
Something that cuts off the extra wind power GOING TO the battery is a disaster waiting to happen.
All the fancy crap in my 'jumpbox' controller resulted in a resistor limiting the charging current.
The manual roughly states ~ "Do not let it charge TOO LONG or the battery can over-charge".
I understand that to mean "the controller is only mentioned in the manual to sell more units, and functionly speaking is nearly pointless".
G-