Bruce, sorry to here about your car, but to be positive that looks like good old metal, so could be manipulated back into shape.
Here in Europe most cars front and rear fenders are made of plastic, to protect pedestrians I was told!
Lots of wild deer here so my front end on my 5 year old car has already been replaced twice, aaggh aaaaggghh!
.
Plastic either gets badly marked with shopping trolleys etc or just explodes into bits!
Ist photo ...... My 5 year old Toyota
2nd Photo ..... Its front 2nd newish bumper.
3rd photo ....... My rear plastic bumper has shopping trolley damage, nope never found who did it. Just a quick clean before sticker.
4th photo ...... Rear bumper with Fieldlines sticker. Marks have gone, excellent.!