Hi Bruce,
I wanted to show this schematic to Ed too, but didn't want to confuse him anymore than I already did ;-)
Your circuit would work very nice too. The max. current of the LM317 is 1.5A, Ed said he needed a bit more. Plus, if this circuit goes into 'overcurrent protection', it drops the load, causing your windgenerator to speed up. This is perfect for a 'normal' voltage regulator, but not for a shunt-regulator for windapplications.
So, in this case I think Ed would be better of using his TIP3055, zener and resistor. Simple & sure to work, unless he makes wiring mistakes.
Ed's solution is probably even better: a bigger battery that's harder to 'overcharge'. Simple & sure to work, if you have the battery. We all have different means and capacities, and what works best for me (like the shunt-regulator) may not be best for Ed... I, on the other hand, have only a few small batteries, so Ed's solution isn't mine :-)
As far as building things from the internet goes (80% or so not working). My experience is that ANYTIME I build something exactly according to someone else's plan but don't understand how/why it works, I fail. When I understand how & why something works, I usually add/change things. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't, but then I have the knowledge to make it work.
My generators are never exact copies of someone else's design; if you understand how/why they work, you can play around a bit, change things, and it'll still work (or maybe even work better for your specific application).
I consider this forum, books and the internet to be a 'source of ideas' and to give me knowledge. I never consider a plan I've found to be a surefire blueprint that'll work right first time. Realizing this (when I was about 14, started with building electronics stuff that never worked, but didn't give up, started studying & understanding electronics) makes the difference between being a slave or a master of electronics (or car-technics, or whatever). Without the right knowledge & just building things 'according to plan', you can only hope it works; if it doesn't, you don't know why. Very frustrating...
To get back to Ed's problem: in your original schematic, the zener didn't have a series resistor to limit current. This would mean that the poor little zener would try to dump ALL excess power above 14V (say,16V-14 = 2V; at 5 amps this would mean 10W). Now you probably used a 0.3W zener (1W maybe?); trying to let it dissipate 10W will not work, it'll blow the zener like a fuse (or perhaps cause it to internally short).
BTW, if you had a REALLY big zener (say, 20-100W) of a value of 13.8V or thereabout, you could use it as a shunt load for windgenerators! Just connect it over your + and - wires like you'd connect a lamp, and you have instant protection. Those zeners do exist, but I've never seen/had one. Probably expensive too. The transistor (2n3055) acts as an 'amplifier' for the zener; you can use a small zener, but in combination with your heavy transistor, it'll work as a heavy, big zener! A bit simple explanation, but not too far from the truth.
Hmm, better stop typing, this answer is getting way too long...
Succes,
Peter,
The Netherlands.