s4w2099
Normally I never take part in any of these mud slinging discussions, it just doesn't interest me. I just try to help people do the best they can.
As you have brought this up then I suppose I ought to at least reply. I have no desire to stop anyone doing anything new if they want to, similarly I don't care if they want to throw away money on things that don't work.
All I try to do is help people get the best from their experiments and if it saves them wasting their money then I hope it may have been worthwhile. I am certain that many people choose to ignore my advice, that's absolutely fine with me. Even if they ignore it and come back later I will still try to help them sort it out.
For those who Don't find my advice helpful then I would prefer thy just ignore it and go away and do their own thing rather than keep pestering me with questions for which they have already made up their mind that they are going to ignore my answers.
I don't mind flogging something for days where someone doesn't get the idea, if it helps them in the end to understand a problem.
I have stated previously that I don't claim to be an expert at anything, when I make mistakes I have admitted it which is all that I can do. I have been at this for a long time and generally I can spot the things that are not going to work. If I can stop someone making silly mistakes then I hoe this is useful.
I don't care what theories people come up with, I judge them by the final result. If that final result goes against my practical findings then normally I just ignore it.
Sometimes I pass comment and they shoot me down, then so be it. When they change the theory to fit the observed results then I take it seriously. If someone consistently produces practical results that don't seem in line with theory then I try to be open minded enough to see it there is something in it. This has been the case with jerry and his strange method of connection . His ideas do have some merit when used in the way that he uses them so the theory has to be adapted to suit the facts.
I think you are hinting at the discussion we have had about very low speed cut in and by a strange coincidence dastardlydan seems to have given you enough evidence to back your ideas. If what he has done performs as claimed then just ignore everything I have said and go ahead and do as you planned. If you also obtain such spectacular results then there is something strange that at present seems impossible and is seriously worth investigating. At this stage I still think the advice I gave you was valid, I look forward to any results that you get.
Flux